Payments and Penalties

Roth conversion. How to pay taxes not from the account being converted.

I am a 57-year-old single retiree. I am looking to convert a fairly sizeable IRA to a Roth probably filling the 24% bracket. I am concerned about getting a large tax bill next April and possibly underpayment penalties and fees. My IRA custodian can take taxes out from the IRA being converted, but I want to pay the taxes with non-IRA money. Can I make a one-time estimated tax payment (fed/PA) at roughly the same time I do the conversion. Can I do this online, or is there a form I would need?

Quick Answer:

Yes, you can make a one-time estimated tax payment to cover the liability from your Roth conversion. Since you are under age 59½, using IRA funds to pay the taxes would likely trigger a 10% early withdrawal penalty on the amount withheld; paying from non-IRA funds avoids this and maximizes the tax-free growth. **Federal:** You can pay online via **IRS Direct Pay** or the **Treasury Direct** website. Select "Estimated Tax" and the applicable tax year. Alternatively, you can mail **Form 1040-ES**. To avoid underpayment penalties, ensure your total annual withholding and timely estimated payments meet the "Safe Harbor" (100% of last year’s tax liability, or 110% if your AGI was over $150,000). **Pennsylvania:** PA taxes retirement distributions at a flat rate (3.07%), but usually only if taken before age 59½. However, since Roth conversions involve federal taxable income, you should verify if your specific plan contributions were previously taxed by PA. You can pay PA estimated taxes online via **myPATH** or by mailing **Form PA-40 ES**. Consult the "Annualized Income Installment Method" (IRS Form 2210) if the conversion happens late in the year to further mitigate penalty risks.

Note: This answer is provided for convenience only. It is important that you speak to a CPA about your individual tax situation.

Share This Answer

Looking For More?

View all Payments and Penalties Questions

View More Questions